When it comes to buying a diamond, clarity can feel like one of the more complicated Cs to decipher. You might hear terms like VS1 and VS2 thrown around, but what do they actually mean? And more importantly, do they really matter?
Both VS1 and VS2 are considered high-quality clarity grades, but they aren’t exactly the same. This guide will break down the differences in plain terms, help you understand when each might be the better choice, and give you a few expert-backed tips to make a confident, informed purchase. Whether you’re shopping online or visiting a local Dallas jewelry store, knowing how VS1 and VS2 differ can help you narrow in on the best option.
What Do VS1 and VS2 Mean?
Diamond clarity refers to the presence, or absence, of internal or external imperfections, known as inclusions and blemishes. The GIA clarity scale ranges from Flawless (FL) to Included (I1–I3). VS1 and VS2 fall into the "Very Slightly Included" category, meaning their imperfections are minor and typically difficult to see under 10x magnification. In Dallas, many shoppers rely on reputable jewelers who use this scale to educate clients on clarity options.
VS1 Clarity Defined
-
VS1 diamonds have very small inclusions that are hard to detect, even under 10x magnification.
-
They are typically “eye-clean,” meaning no flaws are visible without magnification.
-
In many cases, the inclusions are located near the edges, making them even less noticeable.
VS2 Clarity Defined
-
VS2 diamonds contain slightly more noticeable inclusions under magnification.
-
In most cases, they are still eye-clean, especially in diamonds under 2 carats.
-
The inclusions may be more centrally located but still do not typically affect brilliance or beauty.
Gemologists often recommend VS2 diamonds for buyers who want to maximize carat weight or choose more intricate cuts without exceeding their budget. With inclusions that are usually minor and hard to detect, VS2 stones strike a balance of beauty and value, a point consistently highlighted by leading grading institutions and experienced jewelers.
Can You See the Difference?
To the naked eye? Likely not. VS1 and VS2 diamonds often look identical without magnification, especially once set in a ring. The differences become more apparent only under a jeweler’s loupe or microscope. When comparing stones at Carbon Diamonds, side-by-side viewing under magnification is one of the best ways to understand these subtle distinctions.
|
Feature |
VS1 |
VS2 |
|
Eye-clean? |
Almost always |
Almost always |
|
Magnification inclusions |
Very difficult to see |
Slightly easier to see |
|
Price |
Higher |
More affordable |
Example: A 1.5-carat lab-grown round diamond from Carbon Diamonds may appear virtually identical in VS1 and VS2 clarity, but the VS2 version might cost hundreds less.
When Does VS1 Make Sense?
VS1 is ideal if you:
-
Are buying a step-cut diamond (emerald, Asscher) that emphasizes clarity.
-
Are selecting a larger diamond (2 carats or more) where inclusions may be more visible.
-
Want peace of mind knowing the diamond has minimal internal imperfections.
When Is VS2 the Smarter Choice?
VS2 offers excellent value for shoppers who:
-
Are choosing brilliant cuts (round, oval, cushion) that naturally hide inclusions.
-
Want to allocate more budget toward carat size, color, or cut.
-
Are looking for a diamond that still appears eye-clean but is more affordable.
Tips for Choosing Between VS1 and VS2
-
Always review the diamond’s certification from a trusted lab (GIA, IGI, etc.).
-
Use high-quality images or video to inspect the stone closely when shopping online.
-
Consult a diamond expert to guide you through the process; Carbon Diamonds offers both in-store and virtual appointments for personalized support.
It’s About What Matters to You
At the end of the day, both VS1 and VS2 diamonds offer excellent clarity and visual beauty. Most buyers won’t see a difference between the two, especially once the diamond is set in a ring. What really matters is how you balance clarity with the other Cs and what feels right for your taste, budget, and priorities. Dallas jewelry experts can walk you through these trade-offs in person or online, ensuring you feel confident in your choice.
Need help deciding? Book a consultation with the Carbon Diamonds team and let us guide you through the process with expert advice and stunning lab-grown options tailored to you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is VS1 better than VS2?
A: Technically, yes, VS1 has slightly fewer and smaller inclusions. But in practice, both are considered high clarity grades, and the difference is rarely visible without magnification.
Q: Should I buy a VS1 or VS2 diamond?
A: It depends on your budget, diamond shape, and preferences. If you're buying a brilliant-cut diamond and want the best value, VS2 is often the smarter choice. For step cuts or larger carat weights, VS1 can provide more peace of mind.
