The precious metals — yellow, rose, and white gold — are indispensable in crafting fine jewelry. Gold has been popular for thousands of years and remains so today. Platinum, a relative newcomer, is also widely used in jewelry design. Each of these precious metals has particular qualities that enhance the color and sparkle of the gemstones paired with them. Delve deeper into our guide comparing gold vs. platinum, exploring the merits of yellow, rose, and white gold alongside platinum. The choice between white gold and platinum significantly impacts the overall quality and perception of fine jewelry.
The Colors of Gold
The natural color of mined gold is in the yellow spectrum. The color of gold can be changed by fusing and dissolving other metals with it. Pure gold is soft and hardened by alloying, making it a long-life material for jewelry.
Silver and copper metals are alloyed with yellow gold to harden the precious metal. Alloying with more copper than silver produces rose gold. White gold has an assembly of alloy metals, including nickel, copper, silver, and tin.
The Pros and Cons of Yellow Gold
Pros
Gold is highly pliable, easily shaped, and fashioned into intricate, delicate designs. At the same time, the metal is highly durable, and it doesn’t rust or tarnish. It can be forged, hammered, welded, engraved, and polished.
Furthermore, jewelry quality gold is alloyed, which gives it strength and long life. These properties make gold an excellent base for necklace chains, fashion rings, earrings, and bracelets. In addition, the durability of forged gold fashioned for gemstone settings holds firmly.
These properties are essentially the same for all jewelry quality yellow, rose, and white gold.
Color Combinations
Yellow gold is a popular hue for jewelry making. Locating the golden shade on a color wheel shows how it complements dark blue and violet gemstones. So, sapphires and amethysts are great pairings. Gold tones also work in harmonious combinations with yellow gemstones, such as citrine, topaz, or yellow diamonds.
Cons
Yellow gold is slightly softer than white gold, which makes it susceptible to dents and scratches.
The Pros and Cons of Rose Gold
Pros
Rose gold has almost identical physical properties to yellow gold. The exceptions are it has a distinctive reddish color and is softer. Both these qualities come from the higher proportion of copper during alloying than is used for yellow gold.
Color Combinations
The warmth of rose gold complements the subtle colors of brown and champagne diamonds. Rose gold provides a sophisticated color palette for stones in the pink spectrum. When paired with rare pink diamonds, rose gold visually increases the depth of color. It can look garish, however, if teamed with the wrong shades of green or blue stones, so color matching is important.
Cons
The only disadvantage to rose gold is it is softer than yellow gold, which makes it more susceptible to dents and scratches.
The Pros and Cons of White Gold
Pros
The color of white gold comes from the white metals it is alloyed with, such as silver and nickel. It tends to have a yellowish tinge after alloying, so it is commonly finished with rhodium plating. The rhodium plated surface gives a strong white reflective finish.
Color Combinations
White is a neutral color, so white gold can be teamed with any colored gemstone.
Cons
White gold can be worked just as well as its yellow and rose-colored counterparts, so there are no significant drawbacks. However, a white gold ring may have to be replated some years down the track. If you use hand sanitizer or are exposed to water containing chlorine often, you will need to polish and replate in rhodium more often. For those who don’t want to deal with that maintenance should consider platinum as an alternative.
The Pros and Cons of Platinum
Pros
Platinum is a naturally white precious metal with a cool reflective surface. Being rarer than gold, platinum is more expensive when used in jewelry. Platinum is a denser metal than gold, which contributes to its weight and durability, making it a preferred choice for sturdy engagement rings. Platinum rings typically contain 95% pure platinum, highlighting its hypoallergenic qualities and its durability, which make it a superior choice for jewelry that can withstand daily wear. Like gold, it is durable and doesn’t tarnish or rust. However, it is significantly harder than gold, making it less susceptible to damage which is better for people with a highly active lifestyle.
Color Combinations
Like white gold, platinum is neutral and goes well with any gemstone color.
Cons
The only disadvantages to platinum are the higher cost and heavier weight. For example, platinum is a great metal for necklaces, bracelets and rings but not earrings, because the heavy weight may pull down more on your ears and cause discomfort.
Choosing Between Gold vs. Platinum for Your Engagement Ring
When deciding between gold and platinum for your engagement ring, several factors come into play. Here are some pros and cons of each metal to help you make an informed decision:
Gold:
Pros:
-
More affordable than platinum, making it a budget-friendly option.
-
Available in a variety of colors, including yellow, white, and rose, offering versatility in design.
-
Can be alloyed with other metals to create different properties and enhance durability.
Cons:
-
Less durable than platinum, making it more susceptible to scratches and wear.
-
White gold may require rhodium plating to maintain its bright white color, necessitating periodic maintenance.
-
Can be more easily damaged compared to the harder platinum.
Platinum:
Pros:
-
Highly durable and resistant to scratches and wear, ideal for active lifestyles.
-
Naturally white color that does not require rhodium plating, maintaining its luster with minimal maintenance.
-
Highly valued for its rarity and exclusivity, adding a touch of luxury to your jewelry.
Cons:
-
More expensive than gold, reflecting its rarity and superior qualities.
-
Heavier than gold due to its high density, which may be a consideration for some wearers.
-
Platinum develops a patina over time, which some people may not prefer, although it can be polished to restore its original shine.
Ultimately, the choice between gold and platinum depends on your personal preferences and budget. If you seek a durable, exclusive metal that exudes luxury, platinum may be the ideal choice. If you prefer a more affordable option with a range of color choices, gold could be the perfect fit for your engagement ring.
The Right Choice For You
So, what’s the best precious metal for your engagement and wedding rings? Many people prefer platinum rings for their durability and minimal maintenance. It’s mainly down to color preference and lifestyle. Yellow gold looks great on dark skin tones, while rose gold can bring out unwanted red tones in fair skin. White gold and platinum are neutral and go well with any skin tone, with platinum naturally retaining its bright white appearance without additional treatments.
The long-term benefits of platinum jewelry include its durability and investment value. White gold rings require periodic rhodium plating to maintain their appearance. When comparing white gold vs platinum, white gold is an alloy that often needs replating, while platinum retains its color and durability over time.
At Carbon Diamonds, we provide expert advice on every aspect of buying your engagement rings and wedding bands. We’ll help you find the perfect combination of gems, settings, and metallic hues. Set up a virtual appointment, or come into our showroom, and let’s get started.
